top of page

The Fear of Responsibility: From the Rejection of Prophets to Dysfunctional Family Systems

Nov 3
9 min read

An interdisciplinary reflection on the Qur'an, human behaviour, freedom, and the courage to change.

 

By Barbara Wilde

 

Introduction: When Truth Threatens the System


Throughout human history, those who have challenged established beliefs, questioned inherited practices, or exposed injustice have frequently encountered resistance.

This recurring phenomenon raises a fundamental question about human nature: why do individuals and communities sometimes reject the very possibility of transformation?

While reflecting on Surah Al-A'raf, the seventh chapter of the Qur'an, I began to recognise a striking parallel between the rejection of prophets by their communities and the psychological dynamics that emerge within dysfunctional family systems when one member develops the awareness and courage to challenge established patterns.

What initially appeared to be a theological observation gradually developed into a broader philosophical reflection on freedom, responsibility, belonging, and the human resistance to change.

At the centre of this reflection lies a proposition:

Human beings may fear the consequences of exercising their freedom more than freedom itself.

And perhaps the greatest resistance to transformation arises when recognising the possibility of change also means accepting responsibility for our choices.


Rembrandt van Rijn, Jeremiah Lamenting the Destruction of Jerusalem, 1630. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam - BWilde Coaching
Rembrandt van Rijn, Jeremiah Lamenting the Destruction of Jerusalem, 1630. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam

 


1. The Prophetic Narrative: Challenging the Established Order


Surah Al-A'raf recounts the experiences of several prophets, including Noah, Hud, Salih, Lot, Shu'ayb, and Moses; although their circumstances differ, their narratives reveal a recurring pattern.

A messenger emerges within a community, challenges established practices, exposes moral or social contradictions, and calls for transformation.

The response is frequently characterised by denial, ridicule, hostility, or threats of exclusion.

Noah is accused of being misguided. Hud is dismissed as foolish and dishonest. Salih encounters opposition from the arrogant leaders of his people. Shu'ayb is threatened with expulsion, while Moses confronts the authority of Pharaoh.

What makes these narratives particularly significant is the relationship between the prophetic message and the existing structures of power.

The prophets do more than introduce alternative beliefs. They challenge the moral foundations upon which their communities have organised themselves.

Accepting their message would require individuals to reconsider inherited traditions, social hierarchies, collective behaviours, and personal responsibilities.

In Surah Al-A'raf 7:70, Hud's people question his invitation to abandon what their ancestors worshipped. The appeal to ancestral tradition becomes a defence against transformation.

This is where I began to recognise a parallel with dysfunctional family systems.

 


2. Dysfunctional Families and the Preservation of the Familiar


Family systems theory offers a useful framework for understanding why individuals and groups resist change.

A family is not simply a collection of independent individuals. It is a relational system governed by explicit and implicit expectations, emotional patterns, roles, and forms of authority.

Within some dysfunctional families, harmful behaviours become normalised across generations.

Silence may be mistaken for loyalty. Obedience may be confused with respect. Emotional suppression may be presented as strength, while questioning established behaviour may be interpreted as betrayal.

These patterns can persist because they preserve a familiar relational equilibrium.

Family systems theory describes this tendency towards maintaining established patterns through the concept of homeostasis.

Even when a system produces suffering, its members may continue reproducing familiar behaviours because change introduces uncertainty.

Now imagine a member of such a family who begins to recognise these dynamics.

Through reflection, education, personal development, or psychological support, this individual develops a different understanding of their experiences.

They begin questioning inherited beliefs, establishing boundaries, and challenging behaviours previously accepted as normal. Their transformation changes the relational dynamics of the family. Therefore, the individual who identifies the dysfunction may subsequently be perceived as the source of the problem. Rather than examining the behaviour being challenged, the system may attempt to discredit the person challenging it. This can involve denial, minimisation, emotional manipulation, scapegoating, or exclusion.

Here, the parallel with the prophetic narratives becomes visible. In both contexts, an individual challenges an established order and encounters resistance from those invested in preserving it.

This is a structural and symbolic comparison, rather than an equation between personal dissent and divine prophethood. In Islamic theology, prophets possess a specific religious mission grounded in revelation. Family members challenging dysfunctional patterns do not thereby acquire prophetic authority.

Nevertheless, the similarities in the social responses to disruptive messages deserve consideration.

 


3. The Real Threat: Responsibility


Initially, we might assume that individuals reject uncomfortable truths because they cannot recognise them; yet I believe the issue is more complex.

Sometimes the greatest obstacle to recognising a truth is the responsibility that recognition would create.

In other words, to acknowledge that a behaviour is harmful means confronting its consequences; therefore, to recognise that a relationship is dysfunctional may require us to reconsider our own contribution to its dynamics.

To understand that a different way of living is possible means questioning whether our previous choices were entirely inevitable: this is where the fear of responsibility emerges.

Human beings frequently explain their circumstances through external forces: family history, social expectations, other people's behaviour, fate, or unfortunate circumstances. Such explanations can be entirely legitimate, but they lead to the belief that our lives are shaped by conditions we have neither chosen nor controlled.

However, explanations can also become mechanisms through which individuals avoid examining the choices that remain available to them, so fatalism may offer psychological relief by reducing the perceived burden of personal agency; If everything is predetermined, personal responsibility appears limited. If our behaviour is entirely attributed to our upbringing, we may feel less compelled to examine how we reproduce it.

If our circumstances are always somebody else's responsibility, we can postpone confronting our own capacity to act; yet the moment we recognise that change is possible, our relationship with responsibility changes.

The possibility of choosing differently challenges the belief that everything had to remain the same.

And this realisation can be profoundly uncomfortable.

 


4. Freedom and the Fear of Consequences


The philosophical implications of this argument connect with the existentialist tradition, particularly the work of Jean-Paul Sartre. He explored the relationship between freedom, choice, and responsibility, arguing that human beings may attempt to escape the implications of their freedom through what he called bad faith.

Bad faith involves denying or obscuring aspects of our freedom by treating ourselves as entirely determined by circumstances or social roles.

Erich Fromm approached a related problem in Escape from Freedom (1941), examining how the experience of freedom can generate insecurity and encourage individuals to seek refuge in conformity or authoritarian structures.

Both perspectives illuminate aspects of the human struggle with autonomy; however, I would like to introduce a distinction: Perhaps what human beings fear most is not freedom itself, but the consequences of the choices freedom makes possible.

Because freedom allows us to imagine alternative futures, choice requires us to act, and then responsibility requires us to acknowledge the consequences of those actions.

Within a dysfunctional family, recognising harmful behaviour may mean accepting the need to apologise, repair relationships, relinquish control, or reconsider long-established beliefs.

Within a community, accepting a transformative message may require questioning authority, redistributing privileges, or confronting collective injustice.

The consequences may be emotional, social, economic, or relational; transformation therefore carries a cost, and the fear of that cost may encourage individuals to defend the familiar, even when the familiar is harmful.

 


5. The Qur'anic Principle of Inner Transformation


Another Qur'anic passage offers a particularly relevant perspective, surah Ar-Ra'd, 13:11, is commonly translated along the following lines:

Indeed, Allah does not change the condition of a people until they change what is in themselves.

This verse belongs to a theological framework in which divine agency and human moral conduct are interconnected. It should not be reduced to a modern psychological theory of individual self-determination.

Nevertheless, it provides an illuminating point of dialogue between theology and psychology, in which collective transformation is connected to an internal process of change.

From a psychological perspective, recognising our patterns, questioning inherited assumptions, and developing greater self-awareness can create the conditions for different behaviours.

From a moral perspective, awareness introduces the possibility of deliberate action; the individual becomes capable of asking not merely what has happened, but what can be done differently.

This movement from explanation towards responsibility is central to my argument.

 


6. The Individual Who Breaks the Pattern


Murray Bowen's family systems theory introduces the concept of differentiation of self: the capacity to maintain one's identity, judgement, and emotional autonomy while remaining connected to others.

Differentiation does not necessarily require rejecting one's family, but it involves developing the ability to think, feel, and act according to one's own considered values, even when those values differ from collective expectations.

Within a dysfunctional system, this process may be experienced by other members as a challenge:

  • A person who establishes healthy boundaries may be accused of selfishness.

  • Someone who questions inherited behaviours may be described as disloyal.

  • An individual who refuses to reproduce destructive patterns may be portrayed as the cause of division.

Yet the underlying issue may be the disruption of an established relational equilibrium, because the person who changes introduces evidence that another way of living is possible, and this possibility has consequences for everyone else.

If one generation can interrupt a destructive pattern, the belief that such behaviour is unavoidable becomes more difficult to maintain.

The individual who breaks the pattern therefore carries a symbolic significance beyond their personal transformation; they demonstrate that inheritance does not have to become destiny.


 

7. Responsibility Without Blame


At this point, an essential ethical distinction must be established: recognising personal responsibility does not mean holding individuals responsible for every circumstance they experience.

Human freedom is influenced by material conditions, psychological experiences, social structures, trauma, disability, and unequal access to resources.

Therefore, a person subjected to violence, neglect, discrimination, or abuse is not responsible for the harm inflicted upon them. Nor does awareness automatically provide the resources or safety necessary to change their circumstances.

Responsibility must therefore be understood in relation to genuine agency and available choices; we may not be responsible for the circumstances into which we were born, we may not have chosen the emotional patterns we inherited, and we may have experienced events that profoundly shaped our understanding of ourselves and the world.

Yet, as awareness develops and circumstances permit, we may acquire greater capacity to decide how we respond to those patterns and whether we continue reproducing them; therefore, this distinction is crucial: Understanding the origins of harmful behaviour does not automatically justify its continuation.

Equally, recognising the possibility of change must never become an excuse to blame those whose circumstances constrain their choices.

Responsibility is meaningful when it is accompanied by compassion, context, and a realistic understanding of human agency.

 


8. The Limits of Our Responsibility


There is another dimension to this reflection: an individual may recognise dysfunction, communicate their understanding, establish boundaries, and offer opportunities for change, but they cannot compel another person to transform.

This brings us back to the prophetic narratives: within the Qur'anic framework, prophets communicate the message, but the moral response belongs to those who receive it.

The messenger cannot make the community choose transformation; similarly, an individual who recognises dysfunctional family patterns cannot assume responsibility for the decisions of every family member:

  • They can communicate.

  • They can act with integrity.

  • They can establish boundaries.

  • They can embody an alternative way of relating.

But the choices of others remain their own; this distinction represents an important expression of emotional maturity.

Taking responsibility for our own choices also means recognising the boundaries of our responsibility for others:

  • We can invite transformation without controlling its outcome.

  • We can speak with clarity without demanding agreement.

  • We can choose a different path while allowing others to remain accountable for theirs.

 

9. From Individual Awareness to Collective Transformation

The relationship between individual and collective responsibility extends beyond families and religious communities, because organisations, institutions, political systems, and societies can reproduce similar mechanisms of resistance.

Individuals who challenge established practices may encounter opposition because their observations threaten existing distributions of authority, privilege, or accountability. This does not mean that every dissenter is correct or that every established system is dysfunctional.

Disagreement alone is not evidence of truth; the validity of a claim must be examined through reasoning, evidence, ethical principles, and context.

Nevertheless, resistance to change can sometimes reveal more about the interests and fears of a system than about the merits of the proposed transformation.

This invites a broader reflection on leadership: authentic leadership is not simply the ability to influence others, but it also involves the willingness to examine one's assumptions, recognise the consequences of one's decisions, and remain accountable for one's conduct.

A leader who encourages responsibility must also be prepared to practise it; similarly, a family seeking healthier relationships must create space for accountability, as well as a community seeking justice must be willing to examine the structures through which injustice is perpetuated.

Transformation becomes possible only when awareness is translated into action.

 

Conclusion: The Courage to Be Responsible

My reflection began with the stories of prophets whose messages were rejected by communities reluctant to abandon established beliefs and practices.

It developed into an examination of dysfunctional family systems, inherited behaviours, freedom, and human resistance to change. At the centre of these apparently different contexts, I recognise a recurring tension between the familiarity of the existing order and the responsibility demanded by transformation.

The past can explain who we have become, our circumstances can influence what we are able to do, and our relationships can shape the choices we perceive as available. Yet awareness can expand our understanding of possibility, and with that possibility comes the responsibility to examine how we choose to act. Perhaps this is why transformation can provoke such profound resistance: it invites us to relinquish the comfort of inevitability; It challenges us to distinguish between what has shaped us and what we continue to choose, and it asks us to recognise that freedom is not merely the existence of alternatives, but the willingness to confront the consequences of selecting among them.

The greatest challenge of human transformation may not be discovering that another way is possible, but accepting responsibility for the choices that make it real.

And perhaps the deepest expression of freedom is precisely this:

The courage to choose, the integrity to accept the consequences, and the wisdom to recognise that each person remains responsible for their own path.

Comments


bottom of page